2020 LGBTQIA+ Starred Review Roundup

It’s time for the 3rd annual roundup of star-studded LGBTQIA+ titles for kids and teens. While stars aren’t everything (especially not to youth), I think it’s interesting to see the types of books that receive praise. Once I have five years of information, I may even write something a bit more in depth. Until then, here is a list!

(Previous lists: 2018, 2019)

A quick comparison from last year’s list shows a decrease in the number of starred reviews: 105 titles received at least 1 star (89 in 2018, 152 in 2019) and 16 titles received 3+ stars (26 in 2018, 38 in 2019). Due to the pandemic, it could be that fewer titles were reviewed or that publication dates were pushed back. Or it could be that, after the boom of LGBTQIA+ publishing in recent years, journals are more reluctant to give stars. For more statistics fun beyond stars and LGBTQIA+ identities, check out the CCBC findings.

Only two of the titles with 3+ stars received Stonewall recognition. Even more interesting is that The Black Flamingo had already been named the 2020 winner before its US publication and still only got 3 stars. (For my thoughts on Stonewall 2021, check out my post at Medal on My Mind.)

Sources: As always, I relied on Jen J’s fabulous starred reviews spreadsheet to tally up the stars. I also used Mombian, LGBTQ Reads, I’m Here, I’m Queer, What the Hell Do I Read?, and Goodreads tagging to help me identify which books had queer content. Those first three sites are absolutely amazing, so follow them for information about new releases or to check out their extensive lists. I also used CCBC Diversity Statistics Book Search, which tracks books with significant representation for a variety of identities, to add any titles I missed.

Disclaimer: I haven’t personally read most these titles, so my including them here is not an endorsement. The titles could have tons of queer content or minimal content. For titles that have been vetted by multiple librarians with positive LGBTQIA+ representation, I’d encourage you to check out the Rainbow Book List and Stonewall Book Award selections. CCBC also has an incredible book search, which I mentioned above.

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

What about 1 or 2 stars? Here’s a link to the full list for curious minds.

PWPublisher’s Weekly
School Library Journal
BCCB = Bulletin for the Center of Children’s Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s